[mrtg] Can Mrtg cause a Router to crash because of the snmp querys?

[Jack Bauguer]

Thanks Sean,

I know what you speak is complete, Common Sense!
But they look at me like an Alien the moment i came up with the idea...


----- Mensaje original ----
De: Sean Cheesman <scheesman at caeveo.com>
Para: "mrtg at lists.oetiker.ch" <mrtg at lists.oetiker.ch>
Enviado: jueves, 9 de octubre, 2008 15:47:09
Asunto: Re: [mrtg] Can Mrtg cause a Router to crash because of the snmp querys?

Re: [mrtg] Can Mrtg cause a Router to crash because of the snmp querys? If your network is so overloaded that a SNMP query per device every 5 minutes causes an implosion, I’d skip the MRTG and re-engineer your network!  SNMP is very low priority and should in no way collapse your network.


On 10/9/08 9:31 AM, "Jack Bauguer" <jbauguer at yahoo.es> wrote:


Hi,
Im trying to build a traffic analyzer based on Mrtg here for my company, (10 big routers 80 switches 80 servers Cisco/Nortel).
There was an argument about creating this Mrtg-Server, some people claim it would be suicidal, because many of the routers and switches operates with heavy traffic and cpu load (about 75-85%) and querying these elements every 5 minutes would collapse the network.
Can somebody give me some feedback on this, I personally dont believe that querying through snmp every 5 minutes can cause such damage on the network, even if they are on high capacity, i think maybe it could cause a small delay on the query but nothing else, right?. I have allready worked in a smaller enviourment and had no problems, but I need some technical arguments to convince these guys, 
any ideas?
regards. JB


      
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.oetiker.ch/pipermail/mrtg/attachments/20081009/e2433a79/attachment.html